NADAguides Misses the Bus on Back to School Vehicles: No Porsche 911


As the new school year approaches, parents and students alike are searching for the ideal car to meet their needs. Whether it’s for the daily commute or a weekend road trip, finding the right vehicle is crucial. However, with so many options on the market, choosing the right car can be a daunting task.

This is where NADAguides comes in. Known for its comprehensive vehicle pricing and information, NADAguides provides a list of recommended back-to-school vehicles. But just how reliable are their recommendations? And are they missing out on some key options?

Choosing the right vehicle is not just a matter of convenience; it’s a matter of safety. With this in mind, let’s take a closer look at NADAguides’ back-to-school vehicle list and explore why the exclusion of the Porsche 911 may be a missed opportunity.

Nadaguides’ Back to School Vehicle List

Nadaguides misses the mark with their back to school vehicle list
Nadaguides misses the mark with their back to school vehicle list

Overview of Nadaguides’ List

NADAguides’ back-to-school vehicle list includes a range of options, from compact cars to SUVs, that are deemed appropriate for students. The list factors in safety, reliability, and affordability, among other criteria, to provide parents and students with a comprehensive guide to selecting the right vehicle for their needs.

Analysis of Vehicles Included and Excluded

While NADAguides’ list provides a good starting point for those in search of a back-to-school vehicle, there are some notable omissions. For example, the list does not include any luxury vehicles, such as the Porsche 911, which could be an attractive option for some families.

On the other hand, the list does include some unexpected choices. For instance, the 2021 Toyota Corolla Hatchback, while a reliable and affordable option, may not be the most practical choice for students who need a vehicle with significant storage capacity.

Comparison with Other Back to School Vehicle Lists

When compared to other back-to-school vehicle lists, NADAguides’ recommendations align with other industry experts. However, there are some notable differences in the types of vehicles recommended. For instance, some lists include hybrids or electric vehicles, which are not included in NADAguides’ recommendations.

Overall, NADAguides’ list provides a solid foundation for those in search of a back-to-school vehicle. However, it’s important to keep in mind that the list may not be all-encompassing and that families should conduct their research before making a final decision.

Porsche 911: A Missed Opportunity?

Safety features, fuel efficiency, and storage capacity are all important factors to consider when choosing a back to school vehicle
Safety features, fuel efficiency, and storage capacity are all important factors to consider when choosing a back to school vehicle

Importance of luxury vehicles in back to school

When it comes to choosing a back-to-school vehicle, many parents and students prioritize safety, affordability, and practicality. However, luxury vehicles can also be a compelling option. Not only do they offer top-of-the-line safety features, but they also provide a sense of style and prestige that can boost confidence and make a statement.

Nadaguides’ exclusion of the Porsche 911

Despite the benefits of luxury vehicles, NADAguides’ back-to-school vehicle list excludes any high-end models, including the Porsche 911. While it’s true that luxury vehicles come with a higher price tag, they also offer unparalleled safety features and technological advancements that can make them a solid investment.

Expert opinion on the Porsche 911 as a back to school vehicle

According to experts, the Porsche 911 is not only a safe and reliable vehicle but also a practical choice for students. With its spacious interior and ample storage capacity, the 911 can easily accommodate backpacks, textbooks, and other school essentials. Furthermore, its cutting-edge safety features, such as automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning, can provide peace of mind for parents and students alike.

In conclusion, while NADAguides may have excluded luxury vehicles from their back-to-school vehicle list, the Porsche 911 is a compelling option that should not be overlooked. With its combination of style, safety, and practicality, it could be the perfect choice for students looking for a high-end vehicle to meet their needs.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Back to School Vehicle

When it comes to selecting the perfect car for back-to-school season, there are several factors to consider. Beyond style and comfort, safety, fuel efficiency, storage capacity, and affordability are key points to keep in mind.

Safety Features

Safety should always be the top priority when choosing a vehicle. Look for cars equipped with advanced safety features like lane departure warning, adaptive cruise control, and blind spot monitoring. In addition, a high safety rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) or the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) can provide added peace of mind.

Fuel Efficiency

A fuel-efficient car is not only better for the environment but also more cost-effective in the long run. Consider a hybrid or electric car if you’re looking to save on gas and reduce your carbon footprint. A car with a high miles-per-gallon (MPG) rating can also help you save at the pump.

Storage Capacity

Whether it’s backpacks, sports equipment, or musical instruments, a back-to-school car should have ample storage space. Look for cars with spacious trunks, fold-down rear seats, and cargo nets or organizers to keep your belongings secure.


Finally, affordability is a crucial factor when choosing a back-to-school car. Consider your budget and look for cars that fit within your price range. Keep in mind that while a luxury car like the Porsche 911 may be tempting, it may not be the most practical choice for a student on a budget.

By considering these factors, you can ensure that you choose a car that is not only stylish and comfortable but also safe, fuel-efficient, spacious, and affordable.

Alternatives to NADAguides’ Back to School Vehicle List

Other Authoritative Sources for Back to School Vehicle Recommendations

While NADAguides is a well-known and respected source for vehicle information, they are not the only option when it comes to finding the perfect back-to-school car. Other authoritative sources provide their own lists of recommended vehicles, each with their own unique perspective.

One such source is Kelley Blue Book. Known for their vehicle valuation and pricing, Kelley Blue Book also offers a list of recommended back-to-school vehicles. Their list includes a range of options, from affordable hatchbacks to SUVs with plenty of cargo space.

Another source is Consumer Reports. Known for their unbiased and thorough reviews, Consumer Reports provides a list of recommended cars for students. Their list includes vehicles with top safety ratings and good fuel economy, making them great options for students on a budget.

Comparison of Recommended Vehicles

When comparing the recommended vehicles from different sources, it’s important to consider each vehicle’s unique features and how they fit your specific needs. Some vehicles may prioritize safety while others prioritize fuel economy or cargo space.

For example, NADAguides recommends the Honda HR-V as a top back-to-school car. Kelley Blue Book, on the other hand, recommends the Mazda CX-30. While both vehicles are small SUVs with good fuel economy, the Mazda CX-30 has a more upscale interior and a more engaging driving experience.

Consumer Reports recommends the Toyota Corolla as a top back-to-school car, with its high safety ratings and affordable price. However, if cargo space is a priority, the Honda Fit may be a better option, with its fold-flat rear seats and versatile cargo area.

Ultimately, the right back-to-school car will depend on your unique needs and preferences. By considering recommendations from multiple sources and comparing the features of each vehicle, you can make an informed decision and find the perfect car for your back-to-school needs.


In summary, choosing the right back-to-school vehicle is a crucial decision that requires careful consideration. While NADAguides provides a comprehensive list of recommended vehicles, their exclusion of luxury cars like the Porsche 911 may leave some parents and students feeling shortchanged.

Factors such as safety features, fuel efficiency, storage capacity, and affordability should all be taken into account when making this decision. It’s essential to do thorough research and consider multiple sources before making a final choice.

Alternative back-to-school vehicle lists, such as those provided by Edmunds and Kelley Blue Book, may offer more diverse and inclusive options. Ultimately, the right vehicle will depend on individual needs and preferences.

When it comes to back-to-school vehicles, don’t settle for less. With the right car, parents and students can enjoy a safe and stress-free school year.


  • Christian Eriksen

    Christian Eriksen is a talented and passionate automotive expert. With a deep interest in vehicles and engines, he has become a reputable source of information in writing news about the auto industry. Christian is not only a talented journalist but also a car enthusiast, always infusing his passion into every line of news and articles. With patience and in-depth knowledge of new brands, models, and trends in the automotive industry, Christian Eriksen ensures that his readers are always provided with the latest and most accurate information. He has given the automotive enthusiast community a detailed look at the world of cars, and helped build a common understanding and passion for this field. With his enthusiasm and talent, Christian Eriksen has made an important contribution to promoting the development and progress of the automotive industry.